Marketing Ideas to Try If You're Feeling Stuck


Marketing Ideas to Try If You're Feeling Stuck


Does this sound familiar?

You post the same content on social media a few times a week…

You send the same updates in your monthly email newsletter…

You host the same events and invite the same people…

And yet, nothing really changes from year to year.

Why?

Well, it’s not because your effort is lacking, or because your ideas aren’t “good enough.”

It’s because you’re expecting the same marketing tactics to deliver different results.

So, if you’re feeling stuck in your nonprofit’s current marketing efforts, here are a few new ideas to get you out of your marketing rut.


✔ Try new video content on social media

One way to get out of a marketing rut is to experiment with a new type of content.

Challenge yourself (or your team) to come up with a new series of short-form videos for social media, like a:

  • FAQ series, answering the top questions people have about your organization
  • “Did You Know?” series, with facts about your industry, nonprofits, your niche, etc.
  • “Get to Know Us” series, highlighting the people who work/volunteer at your nonprofit

Don’t be afraid to recruit volunteers, board members, and staff outside of the marketing department to help with filming, too.

Try out your new short-form video series for a few months and track which videos get the most views and engagement. Then, let the data tell you whether you should keep going with the same series, make a few adjustments, or try something new altogether.

Experimentation is key for content creation, especially with short-form video!


✔ Try something different from your monthly newsletter

Another way to get out of your marketing rut is to try out a new type of email marketing. Something different than your monthly newsletter. There are a few ways you can do this.

→ You can make small (but impactful) adjustments to your current newsletter

Rethink the format. Add a new section or two. Try sending something shorter or longer. Rename or redesign it. Include some never-before-seen event photos or updated staff photos. There are endless ways to make the same old newsletter fun and exciting.

→ You can try something totally brand-new or out of your comfort zone

If your newsletters are usually word-heavy, try out a completely visual newsletter. Or, if you lean heavier on visuals, try to flex your writing muscles. Leave your comfort zone behind and experiment with something entirely new. You never know what will stick!

And remember: If you’re not sure what your audience will like, you can always ask them!

Add a short survey to your next email and ask people what they want to see more of, what they want to see less of, and how you can make every email worth their time.


Don’t forget to segment your email list for maximum engagement! Learn more about segmentation in my previous newsletter, “3 Segments Your Nonprofit's Email Marketing Needs!”


✔ Try a new marketing plan for events

The last suggestion I have for getting out of your marketing rut is trying out a new marketing plan for your nonprofit’s events.

Come together with your staff, the board, and your event committee to think about new, fresh ways to promote your event, beyond just your own email list and social media marketing.

Here are a few questions you and your team can explore in your brainstorming session:

  • Can you get a sponsor for event ads? Who might be interested?
  • How can you make it easier for sponsors to help with personal invites?
  • How can you get the invitation in front of new people (with a limited budget)?
  • How can you make it easier for sponsors/volunteers/staff to share event info online?
  • Can you offer an incentive or prize for the board member who brings the most guests?
  • Can you partner with another group or community event for marketing/cross-promotion?

This is a great opportunity for you to think outside the box, too.

Maybe there’s a promotion idea you’ve been thinking about but haven’t had time to execute yet, or there’s something exciting you’ve seen another organization do that you’d like to try.

Being in a marketing rut can feel like a drawback, but a lot of the time, it’s actually an opportunity. Make sure you use it!

All it takes is one new idea to change your marketing game forever.

See you in two weeks!

Catrina


Catrina Ossmann, Clever Ideas Marketing®, works with nonprofits and community organizations to increase awareness and reach with consistent and effective marketing.

Have questions? Reply to this email!

PO Box 1547, Adrian, MI 49221
Unsubscribe · Preferences

© 2025 Catrina Ossmann - Clever Ideas Marketing®

Clever Ideas for Nonprofits

Looking for new ways to grow your nonprofit? Get new ideas for promoting your organization online and in the community.

Read more from Clever Ideas for Nonprofits

The Key to Better Promotions? Integrated Efforts. Your nonprofit has an upcoming event or fundraiser that you need to start promoting. Do you go all-in on social media? Do you focus entirely on printing flyers? Or do you put everything into email marketing? There are so many different ways you can tackle your promotion efforts… but the truth is that picking just one promotion method can do more harm than good. The risk of going too narrow with promotions Say you decide to promote your next...

clever ideas for nonprofits with lightbulb graphic

Why Sharing Social Media Tasks Isn't as Helpful As You Think In the nonprofit world, it’s not uncommon to see multiple people sharing social media marketing responsibilities. Staff and volunteers split up what needs to be done for social, with different people taking on different tasks on different days. Now, for nonprofit professionals wearing multiple hats, spreading out social media tasks can be a huge help — especially if you’re already juggling a million daily tasks. But does sharing the...

How to Use Email to Support Your Fundraising Efforts Nonprofit fundraising and marketing are separate endeavors, but your marketing plan should be working to support your fundraising efforts. Fundraising is about raising money, building donor relationships, and growing the organization. Marketing is about raising awareness, engaging your audience, and boosting visibility. Here are three ways you can use email marketing to support your nonprofit fundraising efforts. 1 — Create a first-time...